Skip to content

Pro-Taiwan media under threat? Talking Show is cutting hours



The weekend slots for the most popular political commentary programme in Taiwan, Talking Show, have been cancelled. The show is known for using real figures and evidence to comment on or criticise the KMT and Ma Ying-jeou. As the majority of Taiwanese media are very pro-KMT and pro-China, to the extent that show hosts, guests or journalists wouldn’t mind making allegations about the Green camp without evidence backing them up and unfairly blaming everything on the Green camp, the show host, Cheng Hung-yi, decided to inject a sense of fairness and make pro-Taiwan arguments. Although he is pro-Taiwan, his arguments and comments are always based on concrete evidence such as published figures or news reports. When he misreads or misinterprets things, he always makes corrections and apologises as soon as he’s spoted them rather than letting them pass.


Talking Show has been the number one political commentary programme in Taiwan for a long time according to Neilson Rating. It has been the most popular since Ma Ying-jeou took office because it has been the only show which looks into issues really concerning Taiwanese, e.g. the economy, petrol prices, government budget, parliamentary process, human rights in Taiwan etc. while other political commentary programmes go on bashing Chen Shui-bian all the time (as if he is still running the country).


The reason given for cutting hours was cost saving but I am really not convinced because a number one show with that level of popularity brings in a lot more revenues from commercials than it costs unless someone tries to block that income or pressurises the company by other means. A lot of people have been asking the TV company, Sanlih, to have a replay of the show during the day and that replay alone can bring in a sizeable income but Sanlih has always refused. The recent political climate and government interferences in the media make people suspect that this has something to do with political pressure.


Coincidentally, the pro-Taiwan weekly magazine, New Taiwan, is now stopping its publication. The government did not make any orders but the National Communications Council (NCC) has allegedly been making trouble to the magazine’s distributors and the Investigation Bureau has allegedly been harassing companies that placed adverts in the magazine. The strategy seems to be cutting off the magazine’s income by harassment so that the magazine wouldn’t survive. I don’t know whether Talking Show has been subject to similar strategies but the KMT government officials seem to really hate the show. Premier and health minister openly accused Talking Show of misleading the public in the parliament during the Chinese toxic milk scandal when the government was the one misleading the public. NCC announced that they would like to start exercising tighter control on political commentary shows. The KMT legislator asked NCC to reprimand Sanlih and Talking Show. Now, Talking Show is cutting hours… are these things just coincidences?


Update: The Talking Show clips on the South News and Taiwan US websites were found to be tempered with a spyware (hacking tool) around 4th Dec. I don’t think the South News or Taiwan US would do this because they’ve been providing this service for ages without any problem. The spyware was put on them after the KMT expressed their resentment towards Talking Show and around the time the hours are being cut. It really arouses suspicion. I honestly don’t know what this spyware does to my computer and its activities if left undetected. Even if it doesn’t do much actual harm to computer or intrude privacy, it’s certainly putting those who are aware of this problem off watching Talking Show on those websites for the time being.




Relevant posts:

Freedom of speech and change in police conduct in Taiwan? (update)

One party state returned to Taiwan?

4 Comments leave one →
  1. dennis permalink
    08/12/2008 02:06

    your “A bit about Taiwan” says…
    Taiwan, also known as Formosa …. various incidents indicate that Ma Ying-jeou and the KMT are colluding with China to sell out Taiwan’s sovereignty in the names of ‘improving relations’ and ‘warming ties’. With the help of biased media, Taiwan is facing a danger that has never been seen before.
    i could not agree with you more Claudia, it saddens me that many taiwanese dont see it that way.

  2. Claudia Jean permalink*
    08/12/2008 15:28

    Hi Dennis,

    Thanks for your support. I actually keep hoping that my view is just off and Ma would prove me wrong by taking different actions but things just keep happening at a very fast pace. I don’t know what else to do to raise awareness among Taiwanese cos they are so ready to accept the views put across by pro-China media and many are so prejudiced against pro-Taiwan groups that they won’t even listen to the good points presented by pro-Taiwan organisations/media.

  3. dennis permalink
    10/12/2008 01:30

    things such as recognising their academic qualifications, etc. i see them as Ma’s strategy to slowly integrate the chinese into the taiwanese society, and given time it will become the norm, before people notice it. i think the general public also underestimate how big an impact the chinese can make by their sheer numbers. private companies will be more than willing to hire chinese over taiwanese because they will work for half the wage for example. i wonder what it will take for Ma voters to wake up and realise that they have voted a chinese-at-heart as their president. i’d have thought that the minimal requirement to become a president is to love his/her own country. the people of taiwan needs to become more educated and less susceptible to propaganda and biased media.


  1. Links 8 December 2008 - David on Formosa

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: